Broken educational system

Angela Watson is a National Board-Certified Teacher with 11 years’ experience in the classroom, plus over a decade of experience as an instructional coach. She wrote this article about the broken educational system.Being an ex-educator, I felt this about sums up education and truth today. —

For many years, most Americans have been asleep. We’ve not been paying attention to the systemic injustices that were building and led us to the point we’re at. The mistrust and dissatisfaction that we’re seeing from many groups of people for many different (and often opposing) reasons–this unrest didn’t come out of nowhere. 

We Cannot Avoid Discussing This Because Teaching is Inherently Political

We’ve allowed corruption in our government and injustice and inequity in our laws. We’ve sat on the sidelines as authority has been taken away from teachers and our students have been short changed, time after time after time. We saw it happening, but didn’t know what to do, or didn’t want to get uncomfortable, or didn’t think it was appropriate to get political or be an activist as a teacher.

Here’s the truth. As educators, we cannot avoid politics. That’s because teaching is inherently political. Our funding, our class sizes, our lack of materials, our testing regulations, our salaries–all the issues we discuss daily with our friends in person and online–these are all issues related to politics. From things decided at the national and state level all the way down to what’s decided by your local school board, politics influences it all.

The curriculum companies your district purchases from? Politics influenced that choice.

The way your students are tested and the way those tests are created and scored? That’s political.

Your district’s official plan for suspending and expelling students? You better believe that’s political.

It all is. So we have to be paying attention to politics if we want to understand our daily lives as educators. We’ve spent far too much time focusing on the symptoms rather than identifying the problems. We’ve complained widely and loudly about the outcomes but refused to take a closer look at how we got there. 

Teacher Bashing + Disregard For Facts = Disaster For Our Schools

We must be seekers of truth, and defenders of truth, or we will continue to fall lockstep into a narrative that ultimately sees us (as educators) as part of the problem. We’ve watched with dismay as the American people lost respect for teachers–somehow, it’s we who have become the enemy. (I’m still baffled as to how we came out of the 2008 recession with teachers being labeled as the greedy ones who don’t care about kids while bankers and corporate executives continue to hold the power and respect.)

Teachers have been increasingly vilified not only by the general public, not only by the left- and right-wing media, but also by our government. This was mostly done by ignoring our voices and expertise (I mean, when was the last time we had an appointed Secretary of Education with actual teaching experience, or a real understanding of what’s best for kids?)

I’ve been concerned about this anti-teacher, anti-public school sentiment that’s been rising for years, and I’ve been speaking out about it for years. However, there seems to be more blatant attacks directed at public school teachers, and our work is being intentionally maligned in many cases.

And when you couple this tradition of teacher-bashing with a stated agenda to withdraw funding from our public schools, and you add in an utter disregard for facts, the results for our schools and our kids could be disastrous.

Dig Deeper to Find Out WHY Truth is Being Manipulated

This is the larger issue: right now, the truth is up for grabs. People are defining it in many ways. There are facts, and there are now apparently, alternative facts. There are easily disprovable lies coming from the lips of leaders in our highest offices–lies that contradict what we have collectively seen with our own eyes and heard with our own ears. 

Which means that our leaders don’t care about getting caught, they care only about discrediting the truth. It’s not that they believe what they’re saying–the goal is to get the American people to believe a set of alternative facts that weave together a specific narrative. Thisnarrative will then allow the government to justify the extreme measures they plan to take next. It doesn’t have to really be true, as long as enough of the American people believe it’s true. 

In order for us to believe them, they cannot encourage us to be people who think for ourselves or listen to any reports apart from those issued directly from the White House via press conferences and the president’s Twitter. They don’t want us to look beyond the little bubble of information they’re disseminating to consider a broader perspective or listen to other viewpoints. They’re openly decrying the media as the “opposition party” and any critical reflection is labeled as “dishonest press.” Not a day goes by that we don’t hear this viewpoint being reinforced from our highest offices so that the American people begin to believe the White House has a monopoly on the truth.

Where Are We Headed?

This is an incredibly dangerous road we’re headed down, and that’s just one reason why so many people are openly outraged now when they’ve been largely silent about corruption and lies perpetuated by government representatives in the past. We’ve never before had a president attempt to turn us against the free press, and openly, repeatedly attack those who attempt to fact check or voice dissension.

We’ve even seen that those in government who dare to question whether his orders are constitutional can and will be fired for doing their jobs. We’re seeing a disregard for our constitution, for checks and balances, for the fundamentals of democracy, for dissent, and for truth.

That is un-American and really quite frightening when you consider what happens to a country when representatives have the power to do whatever they want without scrutiny from the people or press, and when any dissenters are terminated. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.

Are we practicing what we preach to our students?

We as teachers cannot fall for this narrative. We must do all the things we teach our students to do:

  • Be critical thinkers.
  • Look for primary sources.
  • Read up on how checks and balances and our democracy are supposed to work.
  • Understand the difference between websites that have a bias and those that do not.
  • Differentiate between fact-based reporting and editorials/opinion pieces on the same website.
  • Recognize point-of-view (which, by the way, is not a bad thing).
  • Distinguish between fact and opinion.
  • Know how propaganda has historically been used by leaders to push false information.
  • Understand how media and journalism have historically been used to fact check and hold leaders accountable.
  • Develop an appreciation for nuance, and let go of the binary that any one person or movement is all good or all bad

Insist on Truth-Telling From Those in Charge and Hold Them accountable

We cannot settle for propaganda. We cannot keep within the bubble of party lines or go along with what everyone else is thinking. We cannot blindly accept what ANY our representatives say as truth–not our president, not our governors, not our district leaders, not our school boards. 

None of them are above scrutiny. This is how democracy works. Patriotism is loyalty to the country, not to a particular representative. It is our job as citizens to be actively involved in our government and hold them accountable for what they say and do.

And this goes for non-government leaders, too. We cannot blindly follow celebrities or figures in religious movements or bloggers or podcasters. No one (including myself) is infallible. No one is 100% right about everything. No one has the complete picture or a monopoly on truth. We have to be continually seeking truth and discerning it for ourselves.

If you like our president’s policies and are that happy he’s doing exactly what he said he would, you can still choose to hold him accountable for telling the truth and allowing our system of checks and balances to function correctly. It does not betray your vote or your party to say, “I choose to think for myself. I do not not see any government leader as the voice or representation of God. I do not blindly follow any one person or take their word as gospel truth. I research for myself. I listen to and learn from opposing views.”

Teachers Are Known for Love of Knowledge, But Not For Challenging the System

Defending knowledge is a part of our collective identity as teachers. Historically, we educators are known for our love of facts, our love of accurate information and our passion for communicating that information to others.We seek out knowledge ourselves and we impart knowledge to our students. This is what we love. This is what we do. This is who we are.

But what we are not known as, historically as teachers, are revolutionaries who challenge the system. Instead, we are rule followers. We are people pleasers. We like things to be peaceful and orderly–in fact, we’ll usually take order over justice most of the time. 

We see ourselves as largely powerless when it comes to creating change within systems that are not designed to support us or our students. And that is how and why we’ve seen our rights be taken away.

This is how we’ve allowed ourselves to be stripped of our funding, our respect as professionals, our ability to make decisions about what’s best for our students. We don’t like to fight. We don’t like to be uncomfortable.  

Teacher friends, it is time to get on board the truth train here. We cannot only be passionate about decorating our classrooms and finding fun activities for our students. We have to be passionate about truth. We have to be lovers of truth and defenders of freedom.

Refuse to Ignore Troubling Patterns or Normalize Deception

Truth is a bipartisan issue. It is something we should all care about and all seek. The election is long over and the issues we’re facing now have nothing to do with whether you’re a registered Democrat or Republican. This is a battle for all Americans, for all people, to fight together.

This is a fight for truth, because truth is what sets us free. Fighting against ignorance and uncovering truth is how we advance together as one nation to end hate and division. 

My challenge to you today is to discern truth. Look for patterns. The news is moving quickly right now but none of it is irrelevant or a distraction–it’s all part of a pattern, a larger agenda. You don’t have to try to keep up with everything that’s happening, but seek out the patterns, the larger narrative that’s being pushed by our leaders and analyze it critically. Fact check the statistics you hear. Question what you’re told. 

My friends, we need you right now. No matter who you voted for. No matter where you stand on the various issues. We need you to be a warrior for truth. We need you to be a thinking, actively involved citizen. We need you to teach students to THINK. 

Get Out of Your Comfort Zone

We need you to fight back against anything that’s not best for our students and the families we serve. Equity for students should be a bipartisan issue. Stand up for yourself, for your school, for kids, for families in your community. 

You have a voice and can amplify the voices of your students and families. Be okay with discomfort. Have the hard conversations instead of discussing “safe” topics that are less controversial. Let your choices be guided not by fear or fear of discomfort, but a love of truth. 

Don’t make decisions by asking yourself, “Am I allowed to do this?” Instead ask yourself, “Is this the right thing to do?”

I know this is battle that many of us did not want to fight. But here we are, teachers, on the front line as defenders of truth. What we teach influences the way the next generation sees the world, and leads the world. Seek truth and fight for justice. And remember, it’s not going to be easy, it’s going to be worth it.